Victim of Domestic Violence experiencing PTSD deemed Disabled and entitled to Reasonable Accommodation under ADA

In a recent New York City Civil Court decision, the Court held that disability due to domestic violence can entitle a tenant to a reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).

Specifically, in Schuhab HDFC v. Delacruz (Case Number: 64402/17), the court held that the tenant’s post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) from domestic violence should entitle her to a probationary order as reasonable accommodation. Under the Fair Housing Act, a landlord is required to provide a handicapped tenant with a reasonable accommodation for the tenant to keep the apartment (42 U.S.C.3605(f(3)(B)). In this case, such reasonable accommodation was in the form of a probationary stay – instead of the tenant getting evicted right away, she was allowed to stay subject to several conditions to prevent any adverse effect to other tenants and guests.

As background, the case was commenced as a holdover landlord-tenant eviction proceeding by Schuab HDFC against the tenant on the grounds that the tenant used or permitted the premises to be used for the distribution and/or sale of controlled substances. The tenant’s defense was that she neither knew of or acquiesced to the illegal activity. She also requested the court grant her a reasonable accommodation in the form of a probationary stay in the premises as a result of her disability from being a victim of domestic violence.

The Court’s decision narrates and incudes the instances of domestic violence that the tenant suffered from her former partner, the resulting PTSD, and the circumstances which led to her partner’s use of the premises for drug activity as testified by the tenant. While considering the tenant’s testimony and her psychiatrist’s input, the Court agreed in finding that the tenant suffers from PTSD and such disability should entitle her to a probationary stay under the Fair Housing Act.

Consequently, the Court granted the landlord a final judgment of possession against the tenant and other occupants, but also granted the probationary stay in the tenant’s favor as a reasonable accommodation under the FHA. The tenant is required to exclude her former partner from the premises, avoid and preclude others from participating in drug-related activity in the premises for a period of two (2) years. In the event of a breach, Petitioner may move for the issuance of a judgment of possession and warrant of eviction.

Real estate professionals should be aware of this decision in order to ensure compliance with the Fair Housing Act and limit exposure to claims of discrimination for refusing to provide reasonable accommodations.

Podcast | Investment Opportunities in a Worst Case Scenario: No Vaccine

New Bankruptcy Filing Procedures in relation to a COVID-19 Mortgage Forbearance

The Coronavirus Aid, Relief, Economic and Security (CARES) Act allows borrowers to request a forbearance on their mortgage. (You can read more about the CARES Act and mortgage forbearance requests in our article HERE.) As bankruptcy filings are expected to rise due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the U.S. Bankruptcy Court system implemented a few system changes to their Case Management/Electronic Case Filing (CM/ECF) Database in relation to borrowers who have requested a forbearance. These changes are effective May 11, 2020.

Specifically, a new bankruptcy event, “Notice of Mortgage Forbearance” was created to docket such event on the CM/ECF database. In addition to clicking such event, a question was also added to ask, “is a Notice of Mortgage Forbearance being filed with this filing?” in relation to established events on Notice of Mortgage Change. This change has been made to prevent filers from choosing the “Notice of Mortgage Change” event when only a forbearance has been obtained.

As the Court works towards streamlining and implementing a more efficient process, readers are advised to contact their counsel to ensure that the Court’s bankruptcy process and its recent changes be followed to a T to prevent any delays or other issues with filings.

Podcast | Foreclosures & Mortgage Modifications - Perspective From The Lender

You can't just decide to stop paying your mortgage without consulting with your Lender. 

In Episode 42, Andrew and Lauren breakdown the cost/benefit analysis of whether you deserve a mortgage modification. We discuss foreclosure lawsuits, mortgage terms and what motivates a modification from your lenders perspective.

In Episode 43, From the initial phone call to the bank, we go through how to get a mortgage forbearance agreement and understand the terms before you find yourself with a much bigger problem. Bob Lund leads the residential lending department at Bethpage Federal Credit Union and shares insights from his perspective.

Click Here for Episode 42

Click Here for Episode 43

Podcast | Tips For Landlords To Renegotiate Lease Terms

Tenants' New Rights: Residential / Commercial Distinction in Fine Print

On May 7, 2020, Governor Cuomo signed Executive Order 202.28 which tackled major changes to landlord-tenant matters in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, including an extension to the eviction moratorium, the usage of security deposits towards rent, and the prohibition on charging late fees.

1. Eviction and Foreclosure Moratorium Extended to August 20, 2020 for Tenants Who Are Unable to Pay Rent or Mortgage Payments due to COVID-19.
On March 7, 2020, Executive Order 202.8 previously ordered an eviction moratorium from March 7 to June 20, 2020. Executive Order 202.28 extends that moratorium to August 20, 2020. Specifically, no proceedings or enforcement may be initiated for residential or commercial tenants on the basis of nonpayment of rent due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Similarly, foreclosure proceedings of any residential or commercial mortgage for nonpayment of such mortgage due to COVID-19 is also prohibited until August 20, 2020.

It is important to note that unlike the Executive Order  202.8 which ordered a moratorium on ALL evictions and foreclosures until June 20, 2020, the extension of the eviction and foreclosure moratorium to August 20, 2020 under Executive Order 202.28 only applies to residential or commercial tenants who are unable to pay their rent and are eligible for unemployment insurance or benefits under state or federal law, or otherwise facing financial hardship due to COVID-19. Thus, eviction proceedings based on breach of material terms under the lease other than nonpayment may start beginning June 20, 2020.

2. Residential Landlords May Apply Security Deposit towards Rent upon Written Agreement.

In addition to the extension of the eviction moratorium, residential landlords, with the tenant’s consent, are now allowed to apply the security deposit and any interest accrued to pay rent in arrears or rent that will become due through a written agreement. If the security deposit is less than one month’s rent, the consent does not constitute the landlord’s waiver for the remaining rent. Executive Order 202.28 expressly allows execution of this written agreement by email. Landlords and tenants should contact counsel prior to making any agreements to ensure that their interests are protected.

Any security deposit used as payment of rent must be replenished by the tenant at the rate of 1/12 the amount used as rent per month and such payments begin 90 days from when the security deposit was used as rent. Alternatively, tenants may retain insurance that provides relief for the landlord in lieu of monthly security deposit replenishment. However, like the extension, the above relief in relation to security deposits only applies to tenants eligible for unemployment insurance or benefits or are otherwise facing financial hardship due to COVID-19.

3. Late Charges for Residential Tenants Prohibited for Periods beginning March 20, 2020 to August 20, 2020.

Executive Order 202.28 also prohibits landlords from demanding or being entitled to any payment, fee, or charge, for late payment of rent pursuant to RPL 238-a occurring from March 20, 2020 to August 20, 2020. This provision only applies to residential properties but take note that it is not limited to tenants who were unable rent to pay due to COVID-19.