LIEB BLOG

Legal Analysts

Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Mediate Your Hurricane Sandy Homeowners' Insurance Claims

Yesterday, Governor Andrew M. Cuomo announced the creation of a voluntary mediation process for homeowners disputing their insurance claims from Hurricane Sandy.

To read the press release, click here.

Under the program, which is regulated by the Department of Financial Services, insurers must offer and pay for the mediation. So, homeowners, take their offer and go mediate your claims.

Remember, mediation is not binding and if you don't like the results, you can simply not make a deal and start a lawsuit.

However, these programs have been utilized in other States after similar natural disasters and, to illustrate, the Florida Department of Insurance had a 92% settlement rate utilizing such a program. So, homeowners seem to feel positive about mediating their homeowners' insurance claims.

Also, homeowners, don't be shy about utilizing the services of an attorney at a mediation. Being represented in a negotiation concerning the technicalities of your insurance policy is always a good idea. To find an attorney who is competent on a given topic, its always a good starting place to contact your local Bar Association.

Good luck.

Monday, February 25, 2013

Suffolk County Minimum Lease Term = 1 Year

Did you know that the Suffolk County Code has a minimum lease term of 1 year?

Did you know that the lease term has to be in writing?

Well these rules are the default rules, at least, and are applicable unless the tenant waives the provision, which also must be in writing pursuant to section 696-3. So, don't simply use a form lease or go month-to-month as you will clearly violate the Code. Instead, write a formal lease and if its for a term of less than 1 year, make sure to include the applicable waiver language.

If you don't, section 696-5 provides that you can be charged with a misdemeanor with a fine of up to $500, plus a private right of action exists that enables the damaged party (tenant) to get attorneys fees and up to $500 by way of the Code.

Sunday, February 24, 2013

Technology of Building Tickets in NYC

While reading the NY Times at the gym this morning, a habit I have to avoid engaging in small talk with strangers in between reps, I was struck by the article SimCity, for Real: Measuring an Untidy Metropolis, which gives a glimpse into the future of buildings, urban planning and enforcement.

The article talks about the future of cities employing science to generate efficiency in terms of water use and energy by analyzing sources of waste through computerized sensors. It discusses a needed future in terms of creating an optimal urban environment with more effective policies for the enforcement of noise ordinances coupled with just plain old common sense of better scheduling of garbage pickup times.

The article focuses on New York University’s Center for Urban Science and Progress and its use of sensors, research and statistics to optimize New York City as its living laboratory. In all, its a great article by Steve Lohr and a must read for anyone who works in real estate.

Yet, what real estate professionals must really focus on is not just the future, but the current state of things. Thankfully, the article also discusses how these technologies are employed today. It explains that in 2010 under Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, New York City set up a team of data scientists for special projects and focused on zoning issues by mining data to predict where to send the City's building inspectors resulting in more than 20,000 complaints. So, landlords and property owners be ware; now you not only have to worry about your neighbors / tenants complaints to the City, but the City is also taking a proactive approach to enforcement. And, yes, the City is correct. Zoning rules are in place to create a safe environment for building occupants. Its time to get to know your Code, understand your tenants rights or SimCity (NYC) will find you and ticket you.

Saturday, February 23, 2013

Lieb School Launches!

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Free CE Class in NYC 3/1/2013 - Deal Killers

Thursday, February 14, 2013

Rental Registration in New York City

Question: Does a Legal Two Family in Queens need a rental permit? 

In general, New York City does not have rental permits per se; however, there are registration requirements for "multiple dwelling" buildings.  The New York State Multiple Dwelling Law defines a "multiple dwelling" as a building containing three or more separate units.  All multiple dwelling buildings in New York City are required to be registered with the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD).

A legal two is classified as a private dwelling since it has less than three units.  This means it does not have to automatically register with HPD in the same way a multiple dwelling must.  However, a one or two family private dwelling must register with HPD if the owner of the building does not reside within the boundaries of New York City.  In that situation, not only must the owner register the building, but he must also register an agent with HPD.  While there are no special licensing or professional requirements for this agent, he must reside within the boundaries of New York City.

If a building is not registered with HPD, the owner may be charged with a misdemeanor and/or fined up to $500 for their first violation.  In addition, any person who assists with a violation of the registration requirement may be charged with the same penalties.  As for broker liability, it can be argued that listing a rental that is not registered with HPD qualifies as assisting in violating the registration requirement; however, this is not explicitly stated.

Registration is extremely easy for an owner to perform and can be done online through HPD's website.  For an introduction into the basics of New York City Rentals, check out this packet provided by HPD.  Useful Information About Housing Rules and Regulations.


Monday, February 11, 2013

Insurance Coverage & Broker's Duty

New York's highest Court, the Court of Appeals, has clarified that an insured need not review its policy if it specifically asks the broker for a particular coverage, and has a right to bring an action against the broker for his failure to obtain such coverage, in its decision in American building Supply Corp. v. Petrocelli Group, Inc., which can be read by clicking here.

This is a scary decision because it will become a he said / she said battle of whether the specific coverage was, in fact, requested, which may be done orally, and it eliminates the duty on members of society (individuals and businesses) to read contracts and be presumed to understand its terms - this is a cleaner way for society to exist where one is responsible for his own contracts.

While the Court places the burden on the insured to prove that he requested the specific coverage, it will be hard to ascertain whether the coverage was specifically requested. In fact, the Court is clear to state that a general request does not create a duty in the broker to obtain the coverage. Yet, how specific must the request be? If you have ever spoken to a lay business owner or property owner you know that it's never as specific as you would like. This will become a ripe area for litigation as to whether the request was made and how specific it was made, which seems to require a trial as it will always be a question of fact.

Additionally, what this author thinks is wrong, an insurance broker does not have a duty to recommend coverage that is not requested, which is also a rule that is reaffirmed in this decision.

Monday, February 04, 2013

Free Continuing Education in NYC 2/12/13: Property Management 101: A Good Piece of Dirt

Friday, February 01, 2013

Free Lieb School CE in East Hampton 2/7/13: The Fair Housing Act

Friday, January 25, 2013

Updated Q & A: NY Real Estate Continuing Education & License Requirements


Does Lieb School report my completed credits to the Department of State (DOS)? Am I responsible for sending my course certificates to the DOS?  Credits received from Lieb School count towards the 22.5 required from the DOS for license renewal. Certificates provided at each class serve as proof of credit hours (think of them as a receipt). After each class, Lieb School submits to the Department of State, Bureau of Educational Standards, all licensee information for successful completion of each course.  Upon license renewal, the DOS will require the original signed certificates if you are selected for an audit. Make sure that you keep your certificates in a safe place. In the event of an audit, the DOS will cross reference the certificates with the student completion records received by each school.   You are responsible for completing all 22.5 credits by your license renewal deadline date. 

How do I renew my New York State Real Estate License? License renewals must be completed online through the Department of State eACCESSny website.   Please note that the renewal process requires licensees to validate education completion by answering “Yes” to the Continuing Education question that confirms all CE requirements have been satisfied.  If you mistakenly answer “No”, the DOS will not renew your license until they see all original course completion certificates.  You also have to hold onto the original course completion certificates in the event of a license audit by the DOS.  

If I did not complete my continuing education requirements before my license expiration date can I get an extension?  Please refer to §177.6 in the Real Estate License Law. The Department of State will only grant extensions in bona fide hardship cases.  Prior to your license expiration: you must submit to the Department of State, a written request for the extension, completed renewal form, fee, and original documentation demonstrating your hardship; i.e., medical documentation.   

-------
more questions answered...

Who regulates my New York State Real Estate License?  Your license is regulated by the Department of State, New York (DOS) and NOT by any real estate school or trade organization.

What are the Continuing Education requirements for real estate agents in NY? Every 2 years, licensed real estate brokers and salespersons in the State of New York are required to take 22.5 continuing education credits. The ONLY mandatory class requirement is at least 3 hours of instruction pertaining to fair housing and/or discrimination in the sale or rental of real property or an interest of real property, within the 2 - year period immediately preceding a renewal.

Are there any exemptions for Continuing Education requirements for real estate agents in New York? 
Licensed real estate brokers who are engaged full time in the real estate business and who have been licensed for at least 15 consecutive years immediately preceding license renewal. This exemption must have been met prior to July 1, 2008.  An attorney admitted to the New York State bar is also exempt from the Continuing Education Requirement.

Am I required to take a course in Fair Housing if my real estate license is grandfathered? A NYS real estate agent does not need to take a course in Fair Housing if they are generally exempt by way of the "grandfather" factor.  Please refer the agent to Real Property Law section 441(3)(a) where it expresses the requirement for real estate agents to take 3 hours in a fair housing and/or discrimination course within a license renewal cycle. The link for the license law where this is discussed is as follows: http://www.dos.ny.gov/licensing/lawbooks/RE-Law.pdf

While reviewing the license law, please refer your attention to the last sentence of this requirement wherein it states: "The provisions of this paragraph shall not apply to any licensed real estate broker who is engaged full time in the real estate business and who has been licensed under this article prior to July 1, 2008 for at least 15 consecutive years immediately proceeding such renewal". This is the "grandfather" factor. 

In general, the only exception to the "grandfather" factor exemption is for NAR's mandatory quadrennial ethics requirement for members of the National Association of REALTORS®. This has nothing to do with licensing or the Department of State, New York. 

If I already completed a continuing education class, can I take the same topic again for credit with a different school in NY within the same license renewal cycle? Real estate continuing education courses are assigned independent approval codes by the Bureau of Educational Standards, Department of State, State of New York.  Licensed real estate agents may take multiple courses in the same topic within each "two year cycle of renewal" as long as each course has an independent approval code. Approval codes are assigned for each approved course, not school and not course topic.  It is advised that you always check your records of previously completed approval codes prior to registration for new courses within your cycle of renewal. 

If I already received credit for taking a continuing education course, can I get credit for taking the same exact course in a different license renewal cycle?  Yes. While New York State Real Estate License Law, 19 NYCRR 177.18(c), states: "No continuing education course will be considered for continuing education credit more than once within the two year cycle of renewal", there is no specific regulation precluding taking the same continuing education course anew in a subsequent and different license renewal cycle.

Do I have to take an Ethics course to renew my license?  Ethics training is not a required course for a Real Estate Broker or Salesperson to maintain their license in full force and effect with the Department of State, New York. Ethics courses may be required by your local Board (trade organization), but are not required to maintain your license with the Department of State of New York.