New Law Calls for Holiday Cheer: Additional Fees on Gift Cards are now Unlawful!

Shoppers and gift givers need not worry about additional fees on Gift Cards/Certificates this holiday season. New York’s new law protects consumers from the predatory business practice of adding fees on gift cards. As mentioned in greater detail on our previous Blog, the law aims to prevent businesses from charging a plethora of additional fees on gift cards. The law further protects consumers from gift card expiration dates of fewer than 9 years, as well as prohibiting declining balances on gift cards over time. In addition, the law allows consumers to redeem remaining balances of $5 or fewer on gift cards.

If businesses are caught in violation of the Law, not only will they end up on Santa’s Naughty List, but businesses may also face court issued injunctions regardless of proof that anyone was injured or damaged because of the violation; and may face court issued fines of not more than $1,000 per violation.

If you purchased or received a gift card with added fees, an expiration date, or a declining balance then the business that issued the gift card may be liable for compensatory damages, punitive damages, penalties, and attorneys’ fees being awarded to the victim. If you believe that you were subjected to this kind of unlawful business practice by a merchant, you should speak to a lawyer and leverage New York General Business Law section 396-i to win your case.

New York to Criminalize Falsifying Vaccination Records

The New York State Legislature passed Bill S4516C, which criminalizes falsifying COVID-19 vaccination records including cards, and the bill awaits the Governor's signature to become effective, as law, immediately when signed. 

The Bill amends the Penal Law to include vaccination cards as a written instrument. For a false vaccination card to be considered a written instrument the card must include either a government logo or something suggesting it was created by a government entity; it must suggest that the card was provided to a person by a vaccine provider; and must includes a date the person received the vaccine, the type of vaccine, and a lot number.

The Bill also amends the Penal Law to include that when someone intentionally alters, in any manner, or destroys computer material indicating that a person did or did not receive a vaccination against COVID-19, it shall be considered the crime of computer tampering in the third degree.

The penalties for violating this new law are class A misdemeanor for tampering with public records in the second degree; class D felony for tampering with public records in the first degree; class A misdemeanor for offering a false instrument for filing in the second degree; class E felony for offering a false instrument for filing in the first degree; class E felony for issuing a false certificate; and class E felony for computer tampering in the third degree. 

Supreme Court Denies Healthcare Workers' Injunction Request on Vaccinate Mandate

The Supreme Court denied an injunctive request by healthcare workers who were required, by regulation, to be vaccinated over dissents by Justices Thomas, Gorsuch, and Alito who said the mandate violated The Free Exercise Clause. 

The basis of the request was that the regulation included exemptions for medical reasons, but not for sincere religious beliefs. According to the 20 workers seeking the injunction, "their religion teaches them to oppose abortion in any form, and because each of the currently available vaccines has depended upon abortion-derived fetal cell lines in its production or testing." 

According to New York State, the reason that no religious exemption existed was because no "sanctioned religious exemption from any organized religion" existed and in fact, religions were "encouraging the opposite." 

Interestingly, the Gorsuch dissent explains that his views on a religious exemption aren't absolute. Instead, he explains that "a State might argue, for example, that it has a compelling interest in achieving herd immunity against certain diseases in a population. It might further contend the most narrowly tailored means to achieve that interest is to restrict vaccine exemptions to a particular number divided in a nondiscriminatory manner between medical and religious objectors. With sufficient evidence to support claims like these, the State might prevail." As such, his main issue is allowing for medical related exemptions and not religious exemptions violates The Free Exercise Clause. 

Regardless, the vaccine mandate may be enforced in the healthcare setting moving forward throughout NYS.  As background, the Second Circuit had previously denied the injunction and also permitted the mandate to be enforced.

 

New York is Ready to Receive Your Calls on Housing Discrimination

The New York State Legislature passed Bill S3437C that establishes a dedicated phone line for public use to voice complaints of housing discrimination. New York State’s Division of Human Rights will operate the phone line during regular business hours. The phone number will be posted on the Division of Human Rights website.

The Bill amends Human Rights Executive Law The General Powers of the Human Rights Division, Section 295 . It awaits the Governor's signature to become effective, as law, 120 days after it is signed.

 

Nothing in this Bill prevents you from hiring an attorney to pursue damages resulting from discriminatory conduct. If you believe that you suffered injuries as a result of housing discrimination, you may be entitled to compensatory damages and punitive damages plus, you can have your attorneys' fees paid for by the defendant. 

Details Released for NYS Mask Mandate Including $1,000 Fines for Each Violation.

New York State's Department of Health issued new details for Governor Hochul's statewide mandate requiring face mask/covering at all indoor public places effective December 13, 2021 until January 15, 2022 (State will re-evaluate after this date), for all persons, over age two and able to medically tolerate a face covering/mask, regardless of vaccination status. Indoor public places are any indoor space that is not a private residence. 

The mandate does not apply to indoor public areas that require proof of vaccination as a condition of entry. However, a business cannot "mix and match" i.e. permit individuals who show proof of vaccination to enter mask free while permitting those who do not present proof of vaccination to enter wearing a mask. Either no one is permitted entry that cannot provide proof of vaccination or everyone must wear a mask (whether vaccinated or not).

For example, in a law office where everyone must show proof of vaccination to enter (employees, clients, vendors, etc.) masks are not required.  However, a retail store that does not require proof of vaccination to enter is required to ensure that all individuals present at the store (employees, customers, etc.) wear face coverings regardless of vaccination status.

Per the Department of Health, the following institutions must ensure everyone over the age of two, unless subject to applicable CDC exceptions, is masked (there is no proof of vaccination option): correctional facilities, detention centers, homeless shelters, transportation hubs, schools.

The new requirements are pursuant to New York State administrative rule 10 NYCRR 2.60.  A violation of any of these requirements is subject to a fine of $1,000 for each violation. Businesses should, thus, immediately ensure compliance or face potential crippling fines.