LIEB BLOG

Legal Analysts

Friday, November 02, 2012

Need disaster relief help?

Click here for the government's website to assist those in need of help and resources.

Flood exclusion to homeowners' policy litigation; Is it coming?

Many homeowners' insurance policies exclude coverage from the effects of flood and surface water or natural water below the surface of the ground without exception. 

As reported by Newsday, LIPA is estimating that 100,000 Long Island area homes and businesses have been devastated. Click here to read the article.  

Therefore, many community members will be seeking insurance to cover their loss. While the flood exclusion sounds pretty straight forward, it may not be. In fact, ambiguities in the exclusionary provisions of an insurance policy are resolved in favor of the insured. So, you should carefully read the exclusion and seek the advice of counsel prior to accepting your insurer's position that you do not have coverage. 

There are also unique situations for businesses with flood insurance. To illustrate, some policies require "safe storage" as a condition to obtaining coverage for valuable papers and records. In this situation, is this a strict requirement for coverage or does it instead have to be correlated (related) to the loss? These are questions that you should consider, research and than fight for your rights.  

However, the exclusion may be clear and you may receive a denial. So, can you sue your insurance broker for your experience of flood-related losses because they did not recommend that you obtained flood insurance or flood insurance with suitable policy limits (how much money will be insured)? The rule is that absent a special relationship with your insurance broker (which rarely exists pursuant to law and facts), your broker has no duty to recommend a special type of insurance. Therefore, you likely cannot sue your broker. 

Stay tuned, later we will discuss FEMA's designation of Flood Plain Areas and requirements for the purchase of flood insurance and how that may effect your loss. 

REALTORS® on the East Coast Help Clients Pick Up the Pieces Following Hurricane Sandy

Hurricane Sandy Damages Could Reach $50B

Thursday, November 01, 2012

Course Cancelled Tonight - 11/1/12

Our continuing education course, Foreclosure and the Economy, scheduled for this evening has been cancelled and will be rescheduled as a result of Hurricane Sandy. Stay tuned for the announcement of our new date.

Hurricane Deductibles - Great News

New York Governor Cuomo announced yesterday that homeowners will not have to pay hurricane deductibles on their claims.

A hurricane deductible is the amount of money a homeowner is responsible to pay for out-of-pocket before their insurance policy will kick in for hurricane related damage. Moreover, while traditional deductibles are generally flat dollar amounts for fire and theft (i.e. $5,000), with a hurricane deductible its often a percentage of the storm damage, which can be quite high (1% to 15%).

To read the Governor's press release, click here.

Voice of Reason: Insuring Your Home's Coverage for Bad Storms


Some great information on homeowners insurance issues from our friends at Douglas Elliman:

The following includes information regarding damage control immediately following Hurricane Sandy. Erik Braunitzer is a writer for Douglas Elliman, brokers for NYC, Long Island and Westchester Real Estate.

Waking up after Sandy, many people in the Northeast are left with a devastating truth: their homes are gone or flooded beyond repair. Some of these homeowners may not be ready for the awful truth that comes next. They may not get their homes back. The truth is homeowner's insurance usually excludes flooding and hurricane damage. If you don't know the ins and outs of your policy before a destructive storm, it will be too late to change your policy later to cover these gaps. Most often, these following areas cause the most issues after devastating destruction.

1. Replacement Value
Replacement value or cost is listed in your homeowners policy and means the value of the loss at the amount it costs to replace an item. For example, if you have property in your home, such as a home computer, you may think that you will get a brand new computer with same features at the original price. However, unless your policy states this exactly in your insurance policy, losses are valued at what they were worth in the condition before the destruction--in this case, a five-year-old computer may only have a value of $200. Replacement-cost-value clauses should always be included in your policy.

2. Flood Insurance
Homeowners insurance policies usually exclude flood coverage, as well as hurricane cover and earthquake coverage. Whatever the cause, floods happen, particularly because of exploding pipes and the amount of rainfall in a hurricane. Floods are actually the most common reason for damage to the home. Some insurance companies include some types of flood coverage. If you live an area susceptible to flooding or if you want to be sure you are covered, adding flood coverage can save you from a lot of financial stress.

3. Negotiating Valuation of Loss
One of the first things that people do after a damaging hurricane is call the insurance company to file a claim. After you file a claim, an appraiser comes to the property and assesses the damage. These appraisers do not work for you. They work for the insurance company. They are looking for the minimum that the insurance company will have to pay in order to meet its obligations. However, you do not have to take that valuation as final. If you can prove the loss is significantly higher, negotiate a settlement with the company. To prove your claim however, you need to take pictures of damage and loss of valuables, as well as keep receipts for repair costs.

4. Hotel Stay or Rental Coverage
If you have this in your policy, it will be listed as "loss-of-use" coverage. This means that the insurance company pays to place you in a hotel while work is being completed on your home, if it is uninhabitable. Not all policies include these types of provisions and others have limitations, such as a maximum per day amount or a time limit for how long expenses are covered. To avoid the out-of-pocket living expenses after a hurricane, ensure that you have loss-of-use coverage. 

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

I'm in contract of sale for real estate damaged by Hurricane Sandy, what's the result?

In answering this question, the first issue is if the damage is material to the contract or is instead merely ancillary. To illustrate, lost electric or a few shingle down is likely immaterial, whereas flooding with structural damage is typically material.

If material, the contract is unenforceable at the option of the purchaser (the seller has no option). In this scenario, if the purchaser does not want to pursue the contract and therefore does not want to close on the real estate transaction, the purchaser can have their deposit (Earnest Money) returned.

If immaterial, the contract is enforceable, but the purchaser has a right to an abatement (reduction) of the purchase price reflecting the damage.

Nonetheless, if there is a prepossession agreement and the purchaser is in possession, regardless if the damage is material, the contract is enforceable as is.

These are the default rules embodied in General Obligation Law 5-1311, but a contract of sale can be drafted to amend these rules however the parties agree. Therefore, it is imperative that you review your contract of sale before you act.

Tuesday, October 30, 2012

Home Repairs & the Law - Homeowners Insurance Policy Tips

First, homeowners policies are all unique and must be read in their entirety. If you have any questions about your policy, you should contact an attorney rather than taking the word of your insurance company because they are not in the business of advocating for you and instead seek to minimize their payments / exposure.

Its important that you don't assume that you do or don't have coverage for a specific loss. There are many gray areas of coverage.

An important item to review in your insurance policy is if it pays Replacement Value or Cash Value for your damaged property.

Replacement Value refers to the cost to replace the property on the same premises with property of comparable material & quality.

Cash Value refers to the cost to replace with new property of like kind & quality, less depreciation.

To be clear, Replacement Value is much better for the insured than Cash Value as there is no depreciation taken into account when evaluating the homeowner's claim.

Next, you should check your deductible, take pictures of your losses, make a list of everything damaged / lost and promptly contact your insurance carrier to provide them with adequate notice (there are generally notice requirements to obtain your insurance coverage, including the way you provide notice and to whom).

Home Repairs & the Law - License Requirement in local Town or Village

While there are statewide laws for home improvement contracts & County / City laws, do not forget to also check your local municipality for their laws as well. Pursuant to General Business Law 775, local laws are permissible regulating home improvement contractors provided their are not inconsistent with State laws. So, a contractor may need to also be licensed on the local level. Additionally, there may be required contract provisions for your job.

While we have substantial damage from the storm throughout the region & need repairs, its important to ensure that these consumer protection statutes are followed by contractors along the way.